|
Post by lilyg on Aug 9, 2018 14:03:35 GMT
Wow brokenbiscuit … then I'm glad you're out. I'm so sorry about it. After my father died my mom had a boyfriend with BPD (we knew because he was a family friend and had lots of drama in his personal relationships and we used to be close years ago before they reunited). It was absolutely hell, he was very manipulative and horribly abusive to her when she got cancer. Even I had to go to therapy to know how to deal with him because my mother was very attached to him and I couldn't just run away from the situation, as I was the main carer of my mother. It was very very hard. When my mother died he took a flight here and tried to take me to a cult (why are they fascinated with that? I had two guys I've never met waiting at my doorstep and calling me on the phone for days while I was grieving my mother). This is very hard for me to tell… but I just have to warn you you're in for a terrible ride if you decide to continue something with this woman if she has BPD and doesn't get treatment. He was very 'kind' and 'romantic' to her and at first I liked him but he started to do some mean things and then oh my god, the bad things he was doing became horrible when dark times came. I think having BPD is very extreme if not treated (not like a person just dealing with an insecure attachment style). Yes, like fatal attraction. As for the opening post, the one who took distance in a romantic relationship should always be the one to close the gap again. I tend to take people on their actions and not on their words. Sometimes people tend to be polite and say things they might mean at that period of time but then decided not to follow through it because x. Just keep doing your own thing, he's an adult. Even if he's FA if he hasn't got in touch it's because, as other posters said, he needs space.
|
|
|
Post by brokenbiscuit on Aug 9, 2018 14:50:50 GMT
Sorry to hear that Lily, that sounds an extremely traumatic experience to go through. Mine pales in comparison
The thing is I don't know if she is truly BPD, or just an extreme AP or just a codependent or a weird mesh of all of the above or none of the above. She is so similar in how she acts to my mother... Loving, kind, a complete caregiver, but with this dark self destructive highly anxious undercurrent to her. This girl left me highly addicted to her.
And then there's me, the FA. Am I really an FA or is it just how I have been forced to act in this relationship. I was with my previous parter for 12 years or so before her, with zero running away, no affairs, nothing. Just a normal marriage that ran its course with a clean amicable break at the end.
Am I really FA? I feel it at the moment, but wasnt before I met this girl. She triggered all sorts of craziness in me. And the worst thing is I am still besotted with her!
Does that make me codependent or BPD as I have traits of both as well. I want to run away to Scotland and unplug the internet and just be the old me again. If she were to ever come back to me again I would be there in a flash, not good.
I always felt I was at blame for our relationship ending as I kept pulling away from her for reasons I couldn't pinpoint, but now I don't know if what we had was a trauma bond of sorts instead. Or if she was the abuser and I couldn't see it. So confused. Everytime I try to unravel the relationship to get closure it just throws more questions at me. I need to just leave it be I think
|
|
|
Post by brokenbiscuit on Aug 9, 2018 14:58:19 GMT
.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 9, 2018 14:59:54 GMT
leave it be and go get a kilt brokenbiscuit 😬 but don't leave us. lol
|
|
|
Post by lilyg on Aug 9, 2018 15:41:29 GMT
Sorry to hear that Lily, that sounds an extremely traumatic experience to go through. Mine pales in comparison The thing is I don't know if she is truly BPD, or just an extreme AP or just a codependent or a weird mesh of all of the above or none of the above. She is so similar in how she acts to my mother... Loving, kind, a complete caregiver, but with this dark self destructive highly anxious undercurrent to her. This girl left me highly addicted to her. And then there's me, the FA. Am I really an FA or is it just how I have been forced to act in this relationship. I was with my previous parter for 12 years or so before her, with zero running away, no affairs, nothing. Just a normal marriage that ran its course with a clean amicable break at the end. Am I really FA? I feel it at the moment, but wasnt before I met this girl. She triggered all sorts of craziness in me. And the worst thing is I am still besotted with her! Does that make me codependent or BPD as I have traits of both as well. I want to run away to Scotland and unplug the internet and just be the old me again. If she were to ever come back to me again I would be there in a flash, not good. I always felt I was at blame for our relationship ending as I kept pulling away from her for reasons I couldn't pinpoint, but now I don't know if what we had was a trauma bond of sorts instead. Or if she was the abuser and I couldn't see it. So confused. Everytime I try to unravel the relationship to get closure it just throws more questions at me. I need to just leave it be I think I understand, Mr Biscuit. I used to really like this guy because when I was a little girl he was super caring, nice and sweet to me. We all carry dark traits but oh my. I guess that's what an extreme BPD person does. It's black/white thinking. We all have anxious and avoidant traits in ourselves, as much as narcisism, low self-esteem, fears etc. We all have the capacity of acting/thinking in many ways. The thing is, if you have been acting in a way that's affecting your overall life in a long-term span, you may have a real problem (a disorder). We often tend to adopt a different role that complements the one we're with. If acting avoidant has never been a problem for you, and you now feel out of control with this one girl, you may have fallen for an abuser. I think everyone, at some low point in their lives, can fall for one (much more if you have something to resolve from your mother's relationship with you). And it is really hard to break away from them. I recommend you to read 'Why does he do that'. It's focused on woman being abused but Lundy (the writer) says sexes can be 'changed'. Maybe it helps you to understand. It helped me a lot. I'm very healed from that Hahaha go to beautiful Scotland! It must be amazing. My guy's from UK and I'd love to do an England/Scotland/Ireland vacation soon with him
|
|
|
Post by brokenbiscuit on Aug 9, 2018 17:07:26 GMT
Certainly haven't been like this my whole life. I've had twenty years of fairly consistent uneventful relationships with minimal drama. Only with this one girl has it all gone crazy, so much so it has sent me to therapy to reflect on my childhood and my behaviour.
I'm still struggling with the idea that it was an abusive relationship. I can't get my head around that. There was no anger or shouting or physical or sexual abuse from either side. We never even raised our voices with each other, not once over three years. All anger between us was directed inwards. Everything was just weird emotional mind games and unspoken dynamics between us. It's all making my head spin thinking about it again.
I've heard of that book before. Thank you, will take a look. I've been on the Out of the Fog website too which is a good resource. I'm still not sure though. Think I just need to stop overthinking all this, it's not healthy.
|
|
|
Post by happyidiot on Aug 9, 2018 21:27:01 GMT
I know that if I’m activated, chasing me up is putting more pressure on me, and I feel manipulated. Going on with your life is different to waiting around, as well. Yes, chasing us FA types can actually push us away even more! We are like stray cats. You don't chase a stray cat you wait for it to come to you When me and my highly AP ex broke up once she sent me videos of her crying, clutching the cuddly toy I had once given her as a present. This terrified me and I saw it for what it (rightly) was which was emotional manipulation. The emotion there was too stark and raw, it made me feel guilty, and it was a blatant attempt to make me feel bad (which it did) and so thus I hid away from her further Thank you both! This is helpful and doing no chasing while enjoying one's life feels like the best way to prevent worrying too much about the FA and if they'll reappear as well. By "waiting" I just meant not contacting them, not sitting around checking my phone obsessing over if they'll text. I think to catch a stray cat you give it treats. Those videos sound like a giant trap and any cat, regardless of attachment style, would be wise to avoid it. Oh and to anyone here apologizing about derailing the thread, I don't mind one bit. Someone close to me has BPD and it's a good conversation.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 2:06:11 GMT
Lets put them in their own box then - and not confuse posters. "There are personality types and disorders that, unlike the four main attachment types, are uncommon and can be considered harmful or "abnormal." This area is for discussion of narcissists, BPD (Borderline Personality Disorder), social anxiety (pathological shyness, agoraphobia, and similar crippling anxieties), histrionic personalities, sadists, psychopaths, and other more-or-less damaged personalities." jebkinnison.com/forums/forum/other-relationship-types-and-issues/hey when did he make a new forum and section? people advocated for this for a long time! thats great! i wish the forum subcategories were the same on this forum :/
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 5:23:52 GMT
it may not matter to you. it matters to some. the reason, is that cluster b can manifest as end of spectrum attachment , and the AP/DA dynamic can still impact ones own attachment style.
I have made it clear in my posting that my mother was not simply AP and i will continue to correlate her anxious style with a dynamic in my life as a dismissive. So, i'm all for people making that distinction, and still taking into account attachment style. I am not for calling a narc a DA or a BPD, an AP. Clarity is important, if it is known. So; i will continue to make distinctions as it fits into my point. It can matter a lot to understand- what happened. Cluster Bs like Jeb said in his article , are like end -of-spectrum attachment styles. Yes there is a difference, as i have said over and over again.
There is a particular poster here that has explored the possibility that her ex that she is still involved with, is a narcissist or some other pathology. Every time she posts, (which is just occasionally ) it seems, someone suggests that this is outside of typical range of attachment style behaviors. She admits it, says he seems like a narc. Yet every time she posts here for insight into his behavior, she refers to him as either FA or DA, or posts in those forums, no mention of any pathology. That's the kind of posting that is misleading, and not clear. She can post what she wants, but she seems to know very well she is asking about a narc when she posts in the avoidant section. She says she does it because this is a forum on attachment style not personality disorder. Still, she could make a distinction and doesn't. That's stuff that is confusing. Directly saying there is a comorbid condition, isn't confusing. There's a comoebid condition in addition to an attachment style. It's not hard.
I haven't conflated the two. Others do, knowingly, Others do, unknowingly. but if a distinction is known and made clear, it can be relevant.
Anyway; we can agree to disagree. My mother's anxious attachment style did play into her dynamic with me, and the different attachment styles between her and i were relevant. She impacted me in a way that would be different from a dismissive narc. Her pathology made the dynamic way beyond typical. But it still was a dynamic.
The reason i brought it up in this thread was to make a distinction between "typical" and a cluster B- because behaviors can over lap, and certainly the behavior was extreme.
It's a matter of communication, is all. that's my take but we don't have to agree. The other forum is empty from what i can see. I'm sure plenty of posters would like to continue here with familiar posters. we shall see?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 5:43:02 GMT
here is just one article in which Jeb refers to a personality disorder as an extreme form of attachment style. jebkinnison.com/2014/07/29/histrionic-personality-seductive-dramatic-theatrical/he has one article explaining the extreme forms, i don't know where it is but it's on his main page. He also talks about malignant narcissists in the end of the dismissive spectrum, etc it's definitely relevant for a dynamic. the behaviors are just EXTREME.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 6:05:22 GMT
brokenbiscuit Am I really FA? I feel it at the moment, but wasnt before I met this girl. She triggered all sorts of craziness in me. And the worst thing is I am still besotted with her! Does that make me codependent or BPD as I have traits of both as well. I want to run away to Scotland and unplug the internet and just be the old me again. If she were to ever come back to me again I would be there in a flash, not good. I always felt I was at blame for our relationship ending as I kept pulling away from her for reasons I couldn't pinpoint, but now I don't know if what we had was a trauma bond of sorts instead. Or if she was the abuser and I couldn't see it. So confused. Everytime I try to unravel the relationship to get closure it just throws more questions at me. I need to just leave it be I think broken biscuit I was in a relationship that, when I became seriously ill, he turned more and more narcissistic and abusive as he gained more power over me. That caused immense damage to me and I subsequently had a series of a few shorter relationships with different variations of Dismissive plus a probable BPD. They were all terribly destructive to myself as well as to my health, which I was trying to recover over many years, plus I was also subject to quite a bit of bullying inside and outside of romantic relationships as a result of the subsequent fragility. Having had a bit of time away from romances, alongside continually working on myself during / between those that I did have, I managed to restore and improve my self to a much more improved version. So - the effects of the Dismissives had a huge negative effect on me, as well as the BPD (where I seriously questioned my sanity at one point)(plus, clearly, the narc) whilst I was particularly vulnerable with physical illness. Having time out to process and reflect is the best option. Looking back after I did showed me just how destructive ALL of those relationships had been to me. The most recent relationship highlighted just how much I have learnt and improved and returned to a stronger version now of who I was before any of them.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 6:07:11 GMT
here is just one article in which Jeb refers to a personality disorder as an extreme form of attachment style. jebkinnison.com/2014/07/29/histrionic-personality-seductive-dramatic-theatrical/he has one article explaining the extreme forms, i don't know where it is but it's on his main page. He also talks about malignant narcissists in the end of the dismissive spectrum, etc it's definitely relevant for a dynamic. the behaviors are just EXTREME. Lets agree to disagree. If I was forced to put personality disorders and mental disorders in a catagori, I would put them in the FA/desorganised/trauma box as the main attatchment style. But thats another story. you could always bring it up with Jeb as the author of the site? His book is informing a lot of people. Some other writers make the connections as well. at any rate, we can disagree
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 17:15:07 GMT
i have an ex i have referred to on here as AP comorbid with some pathology. here is the deal on that: his behavior was textbook AP. His attachment style, most likely insecure, most likely AP.. To the list of common AP protest behaviors, add what Jeb has referred to as an "impotent rage" A rage culminating in violence. This man was evaluated by a clinical psychologist and team of mental health professionals as well as child advocates during our custody evaluation, over the course of one entire year. He was evaluated also using specific test like the MMPI 2. I was evaluated using all the same protocols as i was a party to this custody case. The clinical psychologist was unable to diagnose him with a specific personality disorder. So, i don't refer to one. But out of respect for the fact that i recognize that violence is end of spectrum behavior and not common to all or even most Anxious Preoccupied people, i mention that there is a comorbid pathology. The emphasis here is the Anxious Preoccupied/Dismissive dynamic and i have not nor will i "normalize " it as typical AP.
Most people here have no clue about a solid diagnosis. Behaviors do overlap as just mentioned by a poster in another thread who says she displays BPD- like behaviors when severely triggered by a BPD.
Does that mean she has BPD? no! at some point, clarifying the distinction between "typical" and "extreme " as it is undestood , must be sufficient to get back to the main point- a dysfunctional dynamic with insecure attachment , either anxious or avoidant, as the reason we are posting. (hopefully focusing on our own dynamic in relation to another person's insecure attachment style and resultant behaviors, extreme or not)
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 17:18:03 GMT
i have an ex i have referred to on here as AP comorbid with some pathology. here is the deal on that: his behavior was textbook AP. His attachment style, most likely insecure, most likely AP. To the list of common AP protest behaviors, add what Jeb has referred to as an "impotent rage" A rage culminating in violence. This man was evaluated by a clinical psychologist and team of mental health professionals as well as child advocates during our custody evaluation, over the course of one entire year. He was evaluated also using specific test like the MMPI 2. I was evaluated using all the same protocols as i was a party to this custody case. My ex: PTSD. The clinical psychologist was unable to diagnose him with a specific personality disorder. So, i don't refer to one. But out of respect for the fact that i recognize that violence is "end of spectrum" behavior and not common to all or even most Anxious Preoccupied people, i mention that there is a comorbid pathology. The emphasis here is the Anxious Preoccupied/Dismissive dynamic and i have not nor will i "normalize " it as typical AP. Also, he bore no resemblance to FA that i can see. Other than an anxious preoccupied pattern. Most people here have no clue about a solid diagnosis for their ex and not a lot of time can or should be spent on it. Behaviors do overlap as just mentioned by a poster in another thread who says she displays BPD- like behaviors when severely triggered by a BPD. Does that mean she has BPD? no! at some point, clarifying the distinction between "typical" and "extreme " as it is undestood , must be sufficient to get back to the main point- a dysfunctional dynamic with insecure attachment , either anxious or avoidant, as the reason we are posting. (hopefully focusing on our own dynamic in relation to another person's insecure attachment style and resultant behaviors, extreme or not)
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 10, 2018 17:50:25 GMT
Juniper, I am sorry you had to go through all of that. With my post, I am not refering to you or your experiences. thank you. you did specifically state that you didn't think that i could refer to my exes as AP. it turns out that with a violent one that was anxious to my avoidant style, yeah, i can. and even so , i don't want to make anyone here feel that i generalize my experience to all or even most AP. so i differentiate, intentionally, out of that respect and to not incite defensiveness that i would certainly understand! i've been on the other side reading extreme DA behavior generalized as standard issue avoidant stuff. I take issue with that as well. i'm just trying to clarify why i write what i do, and why it's important and relevant for me, to write what i do. Thanks for your understanding, i truly appreciate where we both are coming from.
|
|