Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 3:54:29 GMT
ah bloom, i'm so glad you've freed yourself from that trap! my advice is meant to help emancipate people from that self-rejecting position. all of us insecurely attached people deny ourselves to our own detriment. it hurts! it never works. it's humiliating. it's not necessary, it's just our conditioning. we have to be free from it to actualize our true selves, our best life, the relationships we desire. so sorry, not sorry. lol! when someone's ready to give up that fight they can find another way. till then, the suffering is BRUTAL.
|
|
|
Post by epicgum on Nov 1, 2018 3:56:16 GMT
ah bloom, i'm so glad you've freed yourself from that trap! my advice is meant to help emancipate people from that self-rejecting position. all of us insecurely attached people deny ourselves to our own detriment. it hurts! it never works. it's humiliating. it's not necessary, it's just our conditioning. we have to be free from it to actualize our true selves, our best life, the relationships we desire. so sorry, not sorry. lol! when someone's ready to give up that fight they can find another way. till then, the suffering is BRUTAL. Could you elaborate on this juniper ?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 4:09:13 GMT
well epicgum, what i see in insecure attachment and particularly the AP nareative, is a self-denying pattern in which one's own needs are suppressed in order to try to fit into the limited space available in an unavailable partner's life. The feel is that love is scarce and has to be extracted little by little with the Most Accomodating Behavior Possible directed at an unavailable partner, leaving the seeker starved and anxious and constantly hoping for change in the resistant mate, instead of adjusting their internal vision and being inspired to find a willing and able love partner. (I understand the process of making that switch isn't easy, but it is indeed possible.) i've seen in stated in so many ways, sometimes so eloquently, it's hard to top the ways i've seen this described by those who suffer themselves. it's heartbreaking. my input from the avoidant perspective seems to be helpful in dispelling some misunderstandings about the avoidant's part in the tango, and i just try to be honest about my observations which may help someone caught in a trap see things another way and recognize their own self -defeating behaviors. and i do this based on my own experience. as an avoidant, the outside looks different but the injuries are very similar- we've just reacted different ways. we all have cut ourselves off from the love that we want and need. we all are emotionally unavailable to ourselves, and to others- until we undertake the journey of self-discovery and healing our own wounds.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 4:23:21 GMT
i would add, someone might come asking for advice as to how to enable this toxic and dysfunctional behavior, which can be harmful to both parties, and i won't do that. i'm not that woman. luckily, it's an open forum where we get to speak with our own voices. disagreements may ensue, but nobody has to accept the limitations of another poster's expectations. we can duke it out if need be, it's happened before and will happen again.
|
|
|
Post by ocarina on Nov 1, 2018 7:00:06 GMT
LOL. NONE OF YOU ARE HUMBLE ENOUGH TO TAKE RESPONSIBILITY FOR CAUSING HURT TO SOMEONE - WHETHER INTENTIONAL OR NOT. YOU ALL ARE LITERALLY SAYING "SORRY, BUT I WAS JUSTIFIED IN CONTINUING TO BERATE YOU". I DO NOT DISPUTE ANY OF THE EXPERIENCES THAT ANY OF YOU HAVE HAD FOR YOUR OWN SELVES. BUT BE HUMBLE ENOUGH TO STOP PREACHING YOUR OWN BELIEFS WHEN YOU CAN SEE THAT SOMEONE IS NOT OPEN TO IT. WHAT DOES IT ACHIEVE TO CONTINUE TO AGGRAVATE SOMEONE? EVEN IF YOU THINK WHAT YOU ARE SAYING IS RIGHT? WHAT DOES IT ACHIEVE TO CONTINUE TO PUSH YOUR OWN BELIEFS AND OWN EXPERIENCES WHEN SOMEONE IS ACTIVELY SAYING "PLEASE STOP SAYING THIS STUFF TO ME"? INCREDIBLE, THAT PEOPLE CAN'T JUST SAY SORRY, THEY HAVE TO INSIST ON SAYING "SORRY YOU WERE HURT, BUT I WAS RIGHT TO SAY WHAT I SAID".
|
|
|
Post by ocarina on Nov 1, 2018 7:04:20 GMT
Sorry. So Beth please can I ask, what do you want? What do you need at this time? It sounds as though life is really difficult at the moment- and that you are feeling attached from all sides as well as hurt and despairing from your relationship. I understand advice is not helpful.
|
|
|
Post by ocarina on Nov 1, 2018 7:05:04 GMT
Ooop attacked not attached!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 12:17:02 GMT
Sorry. So Beth please can I ask, what do you want? What do you need at this time? It sounds as though life is really difficult at the moment- and that you are feeling attached from all sides as well as hurt and despairing from your relationship. I understand advice is not helpful. beth came looking for advice on how to communicate with the DA but didn't get the advice she was looking for. instead people offered their own perspectives.
|
|
|
Post by 8675309 on Nov 1, 2018 12:32:28 GMT
This is the nature of forums.
I didnt read every post in that thread but people were coming from a place of well intentioned help.
I have no dog in this fight but what I see from the outside looking in... is you're in an emotional place and blinded right now. Im not telling you how to feel, etc, Im an outsider, its just what I see in that thread and even this thread. Im a secure type that stumbled here with my own DA person issue so I get it. I have walked in your shoes dealing with an avoidant and I still see your emotions are hot.
Maybe take a step back and revisit when your emotions are not running so hot. You may be able to see people were trying to help and accept people are not always going to say what you want hear, even if well intentioned. People are people. Even if you had this talk with a group in person, they are not all going to say what you want to hear and you could be feeling just like you are right now.
Not much sugar coating here and thats how it should be. Sugar doesn't heal you. This place is a tool to use during ones healing journey. Im hardcore no sugar coat so I do hold back a bit on what I post, I am my sun sign but people are not like me so I cant just yell. WHAT ARE YOU DOING TO YOURSELF?!? STOP THE MADNESS!! haha. I know people are emotionally different so I cant yell that at them! LOL
This is a also public forum, you post it, you own what comes with it.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 12:35:50 GMT
Sorry. So Beth please can I ask, what do you want? What do you need at this time? It sounds as though life is really difficult at the moment- and that you are feeling attached from all sides as well as hurt and despairing from your relationship. I understand advice is not helpful. beth came looking for advice on how to communicate with the DA but didn't get the advice she was looking for. instead people offered their own perspectives. Exactly. It's not congruent for me to give someone the advice they are asking for when it sounds like their choices are being made from a position of a lack of power in their lives - I don't think that is helpful, I think it's enabling. I never ask my sisters for "guy advice" anymore - they always tell me what I want to hear, often it's delusional and I recognise that in hindsight ("he sounds like he broke up with you because he's scared of how much he likes you"). They do it because they care more about "making the situation okay" and fixing everything in the now rather than sitting in the unknown and the vulnerability of rejection or unrequited love - they don't want to connect to that in themselves when they give advice, and they rescue because it was their job in the family just as much as mine, but even if it's a warm hug of what I wanted to hear, it is more about their discomfort around me being unhappy that motivates them to fix and I don't learn. The truth really liberates.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 12:50:41 GMT
beth came looking for advice on how to communicate with the DA but didn't get the advice she was looking for. instead people offered their own perspectives. Exactly. It's not congruent for me to give someone the advice they are asking for when it sounds like their choices are being made from a position of a lack of power in their lives - I don't think that is helpful, I think it's enabling. I never ask my sisters for "guy advice" anymore - they always tell me what I want to hear, often it's delusional and I recognise that in hindsight ("he sounds like he broke up with you because he's scared of how much he likes you"). They do it because they care more about "making the situation okay" and fixing everything in the now rather than sitting in the unknown and the vulnerability of rejection or unrequited love - they don't want to connect to that in themselves when they give advice, and they rescue because it was their job in the family just as much as mine, but even if it's a warm hug of what I wanted to hear, it is more about their discomfort around me being unhappy that motivates them to fix and I don't learn. The truth really liberates. beth came here with a failed situation looking for dysfunctional advice and didn't get it. instead, posters observed a failed situation and offered a lot of respectful and insightful advice and support that's truly in line with proven experience and the LITERATURE. beth didn't like it and is now flaming and attacking. sure, she's in pain. and she's acting out. AP style. ok. i'm not going to molly coddle that. anyone can that wants to but it won't be me.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Nov 1, 2018 13:41:25 GMT
I am extending an invitation beth for you to read back over my posts here on these forums...perhaps in reading through my story you will find some similarities....click on my name...go to view posts and click on the farthest out page (which will bring up my earliest posts). I think sometimes it helps to know that we are not alone in our grief. I wish you well on your journey.
|
|
|
Post by epicgum on Nov 1, 2018 14:26:34 GMT
My 2 cents. I'm rereading a book "Frientimacy" about intimacy in friendships and it has a line that jumped out at me:
"people are most likely to change when they feel strong and safe and loved"
I think if your advice, regardless of its content, is not doing that, then it is unlikely to be effective. Part of feeling loved is feeling heard and understood.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 1, 2018 14:37:06 GMT
My 2 cents. I'm rereading a book "Frientimacy" about intimacy in friendships and it has a line that jumped out at me: "people are most likely to change when they feel strong and safe and loved" I think if your advice, regardless of its content, is not doing that, then it is unlikely to be effective. Part of feeling loved is feeling heard and understood. the thing is, we are all anonymously offering the advice we have. it is isn't effective, it isn't effective. this isn't a paid therapy session with a relationship and rapport. this is people sharing on an internet forum. if it isn't helpful to OP then maybe therapy would be, she just asked for advice on a forum. there are other venues where she can find what she needs. i have a different perspective of a forum than i do of a support group with real life relationship (identities are actually known and face to face meetings are undertaken- totally different venue and level of engagement.
|
|
|
Post by epicgum on Nov 1, 2018 15:18:51 GMT
My 2 cents. I'm rereading a book "Frientimacy" about intimacy in friendships and it has a line that jumped out at me: "people are most likely to change when they feel strong and safe and loved" I think if your advice, regardless of its content, is not doing that, then it is unlikely to be effective. Part of feeling loved is feeling heard and understood. the thing is, we are all anonymously offering the advice we have. it is isn't effective, it isn't effective. this isn't a paid therapy session with a relationship and rapport. this is people sharing on an internet forum. if it isn't helpful to OP then maybe therapy would be, she just asked for advice on a forum. there are other venues where she can find what she needs. i have a different perspective of a forum than i do of a support group with real life relationship (identities are actually known and face to face meetings are undertaken- totally different venue and level of engagement. Just my thoughts. Not looking to fight. Take what you want and leave the rest. (It is an interesting anthropological question about digital communities/avatars/what we owe each other though, I was pretty into that stuff a few years back. I could probably spend all day discussing it, but alas... life!)
|
|