|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 18:52:55 GMT
tnr9 Look, he knows where you live, he has mutual friends in common. You aren't abandoning him--if he is really in trouble and needs you, he will be able to find you and you will be there for him. and, he needs friends that are happy when he does well, instead of sad. happy he is succeeding. instead of feeling left out. this whole thing isn't love, it isn't friendship. its based on unrequited love. its toxic. I understand Juniper...I am actually happy for his successes...it is the hanging out bit that does not work at this time.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 19:00:26 GMT
You're misunderstanding me. The goal here is for her to disconnect from him. If doing it in a way that makes her comfortable and willing to stick with it and avoids further rumination (oh no, I feel guilty for abandoning him, what is he thinking about it) is where she's at, then great, if that's what she needs to clear her head and focus on herself... as long as the disconnection in action has been completed. If you read my "draft," it said nothing about her taking responsibility for the situation for the both of them or anything other than a couple factual sentences and telling him to respect it. Then cut it, it's done, and she can focus on herself. I get what you are saying. If you go back and read all of her posts, it is clear she still wants a relationship and still agonizes over every word, text, social media post, etc. She is not feeling guilty for abandoning him as he has already left the relationship long ago. There is nothing to abandon. This is textbook AP protest behavior. So, our goal is for her to disconnect from him. Her goal is to stay where she is at. Kwim? No, you did not say she's taking responsibility, she said that in an earlier post. She wanted to convey that she was taking responsibility for herself and her feelings. Ok...maybe I was referring to responsibility a bit differently...I was speaking to my normal route of enmeshment where I make a decision based off of what the other person wants versus what is best for me. It did feel like a small victory in the moment. I know he has left the relationship...I know the issues are on my side...I am not holding him accountable or responsible for my feelings...is that not a bit of progress from when I first started here?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 5, 2018 19:02:25 GMT
i appreciate your sincerity and goodness tnr9, but i think you insult other people's intelligence when you call this obsession "love". it's attachment. your attention is focused on yourself and what you have or do not have from him, since the breakup. it is a wounded agenda. maybe you believe it's love. but i think a lot of people would disagree. that's what stands out about to me your posting- it is as though you elevate your obsession with him into some kind of selfless altruistic love and i do not believe that is the reality. it just doesn't seem to be about loving him, it seems to be about longing for him and those are remarkably different things. i really think if you were able to release him to live his life, forgive him for making the mistake he did with you, , which he tried to clean up by getting honest with you and breaking it off... if you could let him go live his life truly free to move on and grow and discover himself authentically, without making it about you, that would be closer to love. i think this obsession punishes you both.
|
|
|
Post by kristyrose on Sept 5, 2018 19:06:43 GMT
tnr9, You are making progress, but know that its ok sometimes to backslide a little too. You are a work in progress like most of us on here, so be very gentle with yourself. It is very hard to see clearly what are actions are saying when we are so close to them. But to me, it still looks like you are solely looking out for B's feelings and monitoring all of his actions as if your actions have control over his. Ignoring him is protest behavior. It can feel like self-care but it's not. If I'm totally honest, when I went NC with my ex, it was to get a reaction until it started to become a healing space and I no longer cared what he felt. My point is, when you start to turn away from him, even just a little, to take care of YOU, you will feel a big difference. Just trying to help with some perspective, but having been on the boards with you since last October, I can very much say you have made lots of progress!!
|
|
|
Post by alexandra on Sept 5, 2018 19:10:19 GMT
is that not a bit of progress from when I first started here? That's where my perspective was coming from. I do see progress and actual decisions being made in the direction towards exiting for the first time. Keep that up, because then the changes have a chance at sticking. We all want to see you get more secure and stop ruminating, and the tough love gives you another solid perspective. But you know you still have a lot of work on yourself ahead, and that's going to be at whatever speed you can do it. We're trying to facilitate you staying on that path of moving forward, staying honest with yourself, and building up your confidence. Hopefully seeing the support, even among the different approaches we may suggest, is enough to be encouraging to keep going and not stay stuck.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 19:15:31 GMT
i appreciate your sincerity and goodness tnr9 , but i think you insult other people's intelligence when you call this obsession "love". it's attachment. your attention is focused on yourself and what you have or do not have from him, since the breakup. it is a wounded agenda. maybe you believe it's love. but i think a lot of people would disagree. that's what stands out about to me your posting- it is as though you elevate your obsession with him into some kind of selfless altruistic love and i do not believe that is the reality. it just doesn't seem to be about loving him, it seems to be about longing for him and those are remarkably different things. i really think if you were able to release him to live his life, forgive him for making the mistake he did with you, , which he tried to clean up by getting honest with you and breaking it off... if you could let him go live his life truly free to move on and grow and discover himself authentically, without making it about you, that would be closer to love. i think this obsession punishes you both. I see your point....I was wondering where the love bit came from and it was stated earlier in my original email idea to him. I am not going to deny the obsession....I am honestly trying to let him go...I think being out of his line of sight will be helpful. I did not handle Sunday in the most mature way....I did not have capacity for that...so I did the best I could. Today is a good day and yes, I can forgive him and yes, I can release him..but I know I have been here before and then I slid....so I am trying to figure out what will help to keep me from sliding back.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 5, 2018 19:20:49 GMT
i appreciate your sincerity and goodness tnr9 , but i think you insult other people's intelligence when you call this obsession "love". it's attachment. your attention is focused on yourself and what you have or do not have from him, since the breakup. it is a wounded agenda. maybe you believe it's love. but i think a lot of people would disagree. that's what stands out about to me your posting- it is as though you elevate your obsession with him into some kind of selfless altruistic love and i do not believe that is the reality. it just doesn't seem to be about loving him, it seems to be about longing for him and those are remarkably different things. i really think if you were able to release him to live his life, forgive him for making the mistake he did with you, , which he tried to clean up by getting honest with you and breaking it off... if you could let him go live his life truly free to move on and grow and discover himself authentically, without making it about you, that would be closer to love. i think this obsession punishes you both. I see your point....I was wondering where the love bit came from and it was stated earlier in my original email idea to him. I am not going to deny the obsession....I am honestly trying to let him go...I think being out of his line of sight will be helpful. I did not handle Sunday in the most mature way....I did not have capacity for that...so I did the best I could. Today is a good day and yes, I can forgive him and yes, I can release him..but I know I have been here before and then I slid....so I am trying to figure out what will help to keep me from sliding back. i have only read a little about limmerance. is that what you have or feel? maybe stop romanticizing your intense feelings and give them more accurate labels? it doesn't mean you're awful- but your behavior isn't love it's dysfunction and i think you do yourself and him a disservice to elevate it with the kind of phrases you use. you might kind of brainwash yourself or stay stuck in illusion with your word choices. i think you are very good and brave and kind but also stuck and looping because you dress up your attachment to him to look like something it's not. attachment behavior is very selfish- AP or avoidant. it's not the good stuff. we all need the good stuff, not this stuff. ❤️ hugs, just keep going. 🌸
|
|
|
Post by alexandra on Sept 5, 2018 19:29:13 GMT
i have only read a little about limmerance. This is an excellent call out. tnr9, have you ever discussed limmerance with your therapist?
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 5, 2018 19:31:24 GMT
i have only read a little about limmerance. This is an excellent call out. tnr9, have you ever discussed limmerance with your therapist? i am ignorant about it but it seems to check some boxes?
|
|
|
Post by happyidiot on Sept 5, 2018 19:43:58 GMT
My stance that it could be ok and healthy to say something to him rather than just not replying to his calls and avoiding him when you see him in public etc without telling him why is not meant to condone saying just anything or sending some kind of apology to him. I support saying something honest, brief and clear that sets a boundary. Part of my reason for this is that it can help close the door to future inauthenticity or waffling if done well. Using the example of when I texted a particular ex (who I'd been in an AP mode with) after I refused to talk to him when I saw him on the street, the reason it made me feel empowered and more able to move on, was that it was honest and set a boundary and I released attachment to any reply or outcome (you could even ask for no reply, if you are at the point of realizing it's better to not be friends and not be in contact). Now, I understand we are not the same and maybe I was in a more secure place at that time. Telling someone you will not be contacting them (or do not want certain forms of contact from them) and why also just feels like the "right" thing to do to me personally. And it can help prevent you from sneaking back in later when you are feeling less secure. If you just ghost someone, there is no closure or having expressed your truth and it is so much easier to then call or message in the future when you are in a different place and back craving to have them back in your life. Which, let's face it, you will be. Yes you might still ruminate thinking "if only I hadn't sent that embarrassing message, maybe I can write and apologize and say I changed my mind," but you also have a great support system on this board to help convince you not to. It's a huge step that you are talking to us instead of him and not making rash AP-fuelled decisions about contacting him or what to say without reflecting first. I think ghosting can feel better because it enables more hope for the future and because we don't have to feel as vulnerable by explaining ourselves. But isn't growing and learning how to be more authentic the goal, as opposed to what just feels better right now?
I dunno, I have been participating in so many threads recently and haven't read all of your past posts about B on this forum, so I don't have as firm a grasp on the backstory as some others here, so you can take my opinions with a grain of salt.
I sometimes feel like a lot of advice I see for APs (like even on dating advice sites that don't specifically label anything in attachment theory terms) is to act more avoidant, hoping the AP person will somehow end up in the middle as secure. But secure isn't in the middle of avoidant and AP. And all the insecure attachment styles have work to do on communicating, on being honest with ourselves and honest with others.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 19:48:09 GMT
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 20:36:49 GMT
My stance that it could be ok and healthy to say something to him rather than just not replying to his calls and avoiding him when you see him in public etc without telling him why is not meant to condone saying just anything or sending some kind of apology to him. I support saying something honest, brief and clear that sets a boundary. Part of my reason for this is that it can help close the door to future inauthenticity or waffling if done well. Using the example of when I texted a particular ex (who I'd been in an AP mode with) after I refused to talk to him when I saw him on the street, the reason it made me feel empowered and more able to move on, was that it was honest and set a boundary and I released attachment to any reply or outcome (you could even ask for no reply, if you are at the point of realizing it's better to not be friends and not be in contact). Now, I understand we are not the same and maybe I was in a more secure place at that time. Telling someone you will not be contacting them (or do not want certain forms of contact from them) and why also just feels like the "right" thing to do to me personally. And it can help prevent you from sneaking back in later when you are feeling less secure. If you just ghost someone, there is no closure or having expressed your truth and it is so much easier to then call or message in the future when you are in a different place and back craving to have them back in your life. Which, let's face it, you will be. Yes you might still ruminate thinking "if only I hadn't sent that embarrassing message, maybe I can write and apologize and say I changed my mind," but you also have a great support system on this board to help convince you not to. It's a huge step that you are talking to us instead of him and not making rash AP-fuelled decisions about contacting him or what to say without reflecting first. I think ghosting can feel better because it enables more hope for the future and because we don't have to feel as vulnerable by explaining ourselves. But isn't growing and learning how to be more authentic the goal, as opposed to what just feels better right now? I dunno, I have been participating in so many threads recently and haven't read all of your past posts about B on this forum, so I don't have as firm a grasp on the backstory as some others here, so you can take my opinions with a grain of salt. I sometimes feel like a lot of advice I see for APs (like even on dating advice sites that don't specifically label anything in attachment theory terms) is to act more avoidant, hoping the AP person will somehow end up in the middle as secure. But secure isn't in the middle of avoidant and AP. And all the insecure attachment styles have work to do on communicating, on being honest with ourselves and honest with others. I do appreciate your advice and for that matter..everyone else's. I don't intend to ignore him...but I also do not want to be rash with a response. Part of growing up is understanding that you can take your time to reply and it will still be ok. I would rather take that approach and have others help me to avoid the traps I have mindlessly stepped into in the past. As many in this thread have pointed out..that is a huge disservice to B and to myself. Under all the attachment stuff, I do care about him and want him to be happy....so I would rather not convey anything that comes across as manipulative..no matter how honest it sounds to me.
|
|
|
Post by kristyrose on Sept 5, 2018 20:39:09 GMT
Tnr9,
You are working so very hard and should be proud of yourself above anything else right now.
|
|
|
Post by lilyg on Sept 5, 2018 21:08:04 GMT
It's ok to write him. You don't have to Ghost him. But after all this time being 'friends' I'd approach it as something much less emotional. Just: hey I'm taking my time to do my own thing. Cool, calm, collected and true. Seems honest and something you won't feel guilty later. You don't have to explain.
Do what you must. We are here.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Sept 5, 2018 21:36:36 GMT
Hang in there tnr9 . This is not an easy process. You don't need to ghost him. You just don't need to explain yourself. Your personal matters stopped being his business when he ended your relationship. You can be friendly and cordial, if he contacts you. Keep it short and on point. (I'm great, thx! Hope you are as well! Soooo busy! Have a great day!😊) Easy to do in text or email no matter how you're feeling. Most importantly, stay off his social media. If you have to delete yours, DO IT. It's for your own sanity. I deleted my FB, etc a while ago because stuff that was coming across my feed was bothering me. Now I can't see it even if I wanted to and I don't care now anyway 😉 Yeh..I thought about sending him a text on Sunday that said..."busy with plans, enjoy the beach🙂"...that would have resolved things enough to keep me from feeling guilty....lesson learned. I considered deleting FB but I am a moderator on a group for minimalists. I did remove myself from the community group's page so I don't see whether he posts anything there....huge relief. Not ready yet to delete him...but have done much better with not checking and I changed my settings so I don't see his activity on my feed or any events he likes etc. I do appreciate everyone's support and tough love....I know I have been in denial for far too long...but I think I am finally grasping that it truly is over.
|
|