|
Post by epicgum on Nov 5, 2018 23:48:18 GMT
Wow, great videos...I don't think I previously appreciated the impact of smartphones on our ability to remain present, and how we might be using these things to escape and numb. I resolve to be more present in real life...while writing this on my phone. It's worth noting that there were similar panics around radio, magazines, books etc. But some how how smartphones feel more powerful. It reminds me a bit of cushbombs perspective in the chapo "great gaming debate" that video games are so powerful and addictive they are substituting life. www.no-cartridge.net/episode-64-live-debate-w-matt-christman-and-virgil-texas-at-the-bell-houseAs for the first video, that makes me wonder if the surge in right wing ideas worldwide isn't related to the latest technological developments and its impact on our ability to empathize with others. Interesting.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 5, 2018 23:55:12 GMT
heres the thing.... whatever we're doing, we should feel bad about it. it's just.... all going down the drain.
just kidding. middle roads. middle roads.
overthinking is a thing. lol! not saying anyone here is doing that but i decline, i'm going to go eat some noodles.
|
|
|
Post by faithopelove on Nov 5, 2018 23:58:37 GMT
heres the thing.... whatever we're doing, we should feel bad about it. it's just.... all going down the drain. just kidding. middle roads. middle roads. overthinking is a thing. lol! not saying anyone here is doing that but i decline, i'm going to go eat some noodles. Lol sounds like a plan..I’m hungry!! 😉
|
|
|
Post by alexandra on Nov 5, 2018 23:59:24 GMT
I'm here because finding this board helped more than anything else to push me over the "last ten yards" so to speak into everything "clicking" for me and my mindset to finish its change from AP to earned secure. I knew a lot, but I didn't quite actually understand it until I started reading through here. Specifically, reading every older FA thread (mostly one of the other attachment types saying, here's what's happened with my FA, why is s/he like this, here's what happened next, things didn't work out) forced me to see that there are very similar patterns that repeat endlessly unless both insecurely attached partners take responsibility for their half. My story was not unique or mysterious, and nothing I could do was ultimately going to change anything unless my partner was as on board with confronting his own issues as I was in regards to my own issues. Not one account told a different story. This was really helpful in regards to removing blame and thinking I wasn't good enough / he wasn't "in love" with me enough to confront his issues (because that's not how this works). I already knew I'd been AP and had worked through that quite a lot before I found the board, but having it as a resource to really understand the work I'd inadvertently done and then being able to read about the experiences of both other insecure types and other APs pairing with other insecures also helped me to "get" it, to understand my entire dating history, and to see healthier ways forward. So I've stuck around because it helped me so much, and I feel I can articulate my insecure experience and actually did earn secure, so I can compare, empathize, and contrast. I can be an AP example of it truly being possible to earn secure (it's not a myth!) and what "realistic" expectations are for the journey and aftermath. I wish I'd been able to figure that out five years ago, and that I'd found someone then who could start the conversation with me about it, and so I want to be a resource for others who are searching for those answers and at least found this board as a starting point. I won't lie, I also get satisfaction in speaking to people who have self-selected to be here and explore this and are (mostly) open to thinking in a different way (ie focus on your own issues and not your partner's), are possibly already aware or are open to awareness about their own insecure attachment, and maybe are getting ready to work on it because I feel like I can be helpful in that situation... and it makes me feel a little less helpless that most of my real life insecure partners never got to that point so there was no growth in those relationships. That at least my going through all that, and all the pain, could still potentially help someone. The self-selection also makes it possible to talk about this with other people who find it interesting and believe in it, and I feel more at liberty to discuss specific issues with people who don't know who my partners are, because I don't want want our mutual friends to know their business. It's also helpful to me to "stay in practice" thinking secure, not slip into bad habits, and get interesting ideas and resources from other people sharing their experiences here. I have some insecurely attached friends in real life who have started their journeys, and I sometimes pass information from here to them. Links, suggestions, book recommendations, etc., which they have found helpful as well. When I first started reading, there were some AP/DA/FA tonal conflicts I read in threads I wasn't actually participating in that made me bristle (I'm looking a little bit at you, juniper!), but I never said anything to anyone about it because I recognized that my sensitivities were coming from AP self-blame patterns that needed to be broken and it would be more productive for me to just sit with that and think about it than get defensive. It was! Now none of that tough love stuff bothers me at all, and I'm not sure if it's because I've come further in earning secure or if it's that I've observed repeatedly that high-level, the people who give tough love on this board have good intentions and come from different perspectives, all of which are valuable and give insight into other types and people. So it made it very clear it was never to be taken personally, which is a hard lesson for most insecures to absorb (because we're insecure!). And there's value in observing the AP/DA (FA) dynamic causing miscommunications and conflict on the board because it makes it more easy to recognize, and maybe to resolve, in real life. In a lot of ways, being here is about learning good conflict resolution and communication skills. When people do get incredibly defensive and repetitive and stay that way, or drop off the board entirely, I feel like that's where they are in their awareness journey and they may need more time or a different medium than this board to get there. Doesn't mean they won't get there on their own timeline, but the same methods don't work for everyone.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 6, 2018 0:04:25 GMT
I'm here because finding this board helped more than anything else to push me over the "last ten yards" so to speak into everything "clicking" for me and my mindset to finish its change from AP to earned secure. I knew a lot, but I didn't quite actually understand it until I started reading through here. Specifically, reading every older FA thread (mostly one of the other attachment types saying, here's what's happened with my FA, why is s/he like this, here's what happened next, things didn't work out) forced me to see that there are very similar patterns that repeat endlessly unless both insecurely attached partners take responsibility for their half. My story was not unique or mysterious, and nothing I could do was ultimately going to change anything unless my partner was as on board with confronting his own issues as I was in regards to my own issues. Not one account told a different story. This was really helpful in regards to removing blame and thinking I wasn't good enough / he wasn't "in love" with me enough to confront his issues (because that's not how this works). I already knew I'd been AP and had worked through that quite a lot before I found the board, but having it as a resource to really understand the work I'd inadvertently done and then being able to read about the experiences of both other insecure types and other APs pairing with other insecures also helped me to "get" it, to understand my entire dating history, and to see healthier ways forward. So I've stuck around because it helped me so much, and I feel I can articulate my insecure experience and actually did earn secure, so I can compare, empathize, and contrast. I can be an AP example of it truly being possible to earn secure (it's not a myth!) and what "realistic" expectations are for the journey and aftermath. I wish I'd been able to figure that out five years ago, and that I'd found someone then who could start the conversation with me about it, and so I want to be a resource for others who are searching for those answers and at least found this board as a starting point. I won't lie, I also get satisfaction in speaking to people who have self-selected to be here and explore this and are (mostly) open to thinking in a different way (ie focus on your own issues and not your partner's), are possibly already aware or are open to awareness about their own insecure attachment, and maybe are getting ready to work on it because I feel like I can be helpful in that situation... and it makes me feel a little less helpless that most of my real life insecure partners never got to that point so there was no growth in those relationships. That at least my going through all that, and all the pain, could still potentially help someone. The self-selection also makes it possible to talk about this with other people who find it interesting and believe in it, and I feel more at liberty to discuss specific issues with people who don't know who my partners are, because I don't want want our mutual friends to know their business. It's also helpful to me to "stay in practice" thinking secure, not slip into bad habits, and get interesting ideas and resources from other people sharing their experiences here. I have some insecurely attached friends in real life who have started their journeys, and I sometimes pass information from here to them. Links, suggestions, book recommendations, etc., which they have found helpful as well. When I first started reading, there were some AP/DA/FA tonal conflicts I read in threads I wasn't actually participating in that made me bristle (I'm looking a little bit at you, juniper!), but I never said anything to anyone about it because I recognized that my sensitivities were coming from AP self-blame patterns that needed to be broken and it would be more productive for me to just sit with that and think about it than get defensive. It was! Now none of that tough love stuff bothers me at all, and I'm not sure if it's because I've come further in earning secure or if it's that I've observed repeatedly that high-level, the people who give tough love on this board have good intentions and come from different perspectives, all of which are valuable and give insight into other types and people. So it made it very clear it was never to be taken personally, which is a hard lesson for most insecures to absorb (because we're insecure!). And there's value in observing the AP/DA (FA) dynamic causing miscommunications and conflict on the board because it makes it more easy to recognize, and maybe to resolve, in real life. In a lot of ways, being here is about learning good conflict resolution and communication skills. When people do get incredibly defensive and repetitive and stay that way, or drop off the board entirely, I feel like that's where they are in their awareness journey and they may need more time or a different medium than this board to get there. Doesn't mean they won't get there on their own timeline, but the same methods don't work for everyone. very well said, i related a lot to this post!! and, believe me, i bristle at AP tones as well, and while i engage plenty it's a pretty consistent thing for me to bite my tongue. so it goes both ways but i too recognize that my response is my response, i don't have to make everyone accountable for it. just love this post!
|
|
|
Post by epicgum on Nov 6, 2018 0:07:52 GMT
heres the thing.... whatever we're doing, we should feel bad about it. it's just.... all going down the drain. just kidding. middle roads. middle roads. overthinking is a thing. lol! not saying anyone here is doing that but i decline, i'm going to go eat some noodles. Oh I overthink all the time. Probably a barrier to one of those "get out of your head and into your body and feel your emotions" things. Dont worry though juniper if I read enough books and think about it enough I am sure i will figure it out!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 6, 2018 0:10:00 GMT
heres the thing.... whatever we're doing, we should feel bad about it. it's just.... all going down the drain. just kidding. middle roads. middle roads. overthinking is a thing. lol! not saying anyone here is doing that but i decline, i'm going to go eat some noodles. Oh I overthink all the time. Probably a barrier to one of those "get out of your head and into your body and feel your emotions" things. Dont worry though juniper if I read enough books and think about it enough I am sure i will figure it out! noooooooooooodles. oodles of noodles. let's jump in a vat of delicious al dente buttery noodles.... last one in's a rotten egg! 😍😘
|
|
|
Post by 8675309 on Nov 6, 2018 0:22:22 GMT
I'll also add, I like forums, specially ones I learn from. Ive used forums since they were born on the net and there are not as many as there used to be, everyone is on facebook. I cant stand FB...
|
|
|
Post by faithopelove on Nov 6, 2018 4:17:30 GMT
I'm here because finding this board helped more than anything else to push me over the "last ten yards" so to speak into everything "clicking" for me and my mindset to finish its change from AP to earned secure. I knew a lot, but I didn't quite actually understand it until I started reading through here. Specifically, reading every older FA thread (mostly one of the other attachment types saying, here's what's happened with my FA, why is s/he like this, here's what happened next, things didn't work out) forced me to see that there are very similar patterns that repeat endlessly unless both insecurely attached partners take responsibility for their half. My story was not unique or mysterious, and nothing I could do was ultimately going to change anything unless my partner was as on board with confronting his own issues as I was in regards to my own issues. Not one account told a different story. This was really helpful in regards to removing blame and thinking I wasn't good enough / he wasn't "in love" with me enough to confront his issues (because that's not how this works). I already knew I'd been AP and had worked through that quite a lot before I found the board, but having it as a resource to really understand the work I'd inadvertently done and then being able to read about the experiences of both other insecure types and other APs pairing with other insecures also helped me to "get" it, to understand my entire dating history, and to see healthier ways forward. So I've stuck around because it helped me so much, and I feel I can articulate my insecure experience and actually did earn secure, so I can compare, empathize, and contrast. I can be an AP example of it truly being possible to earn secure (it's not a myth!) and what "realistic" expectations are for the journey and aftermath. I wish I'd been able to figure that out five years ago, and that I'd found someone then who could start the conversation with me about it, and so I want to be a resource for others who are searching for those answers and at least found this board as a starting point. I won't lie, I also get satisfaction in speaking to people who have self-selected to be here and explore this and are (mostly) open to thinking in a different way (ie focus on your own issues and not your partner's), are possibly already aware or are open to awareness about their own insecure attachment, and maybe are getting ready to work on it because I feel like I can be helpful in that situation... and it makes me feel a little less helpless that most of my real life insecure partners never got to that point so there was no growth in those relationships. That at least my going through all that, and all the pain, could still potentially help someone. The self-selection also makes it possible to talk about this with other people who find it interesting and believe in it, and I feel more at liberty to discuss specific issues with people who don't know who my partners are, because I don't want want our mutual friends to know their business. It's also helpful to me to "stay in practice" thinking secure, not slip into bad habits, and get interesting ideas and resources from other people sharing their experiences here. I have some insecurely attached friends in real life who have started their journeys, and I sometimes pass information from here to them. Links, suggestions, book recommendations, etc., which they have found helpful as well. When I first started reading, there were some AP/DA/FA tonal conflicts I read in threads I wasn't actually participating in that made me bristle (I'm looking a little bit at you, juniper!), but I never said anything to anyone about it because I recognized that my sensitivities were coming from AP self-blame patterns that needed to be broken and it would be more productive for me to just sit with that and think about it than get defensive. It was! Now none of that tough love stuff bothers me at all, and I'm not sure if it's because I've come further in earning secure or if it's that I've observed repeatedly that high-level, the people who give tough love on this board have good intentions and come from different perspectives, all of which are valuable and give insight into other types and people. So it made it very clear it was never to be taken personally, which is a hard lesson for most insecures to absorb (because we're insecure!). And there's value in observing the AP/DA (FA) dynamic causing miscommunications and conflict on the board because it makes it more easy to recognize, and maybe to resolve, in real life. In a lot of ways, being here is about learning good conflict resolution and communication skills. When people do get incredibly defensive and repetitive and stay that way, or drop off the board entirely, I feel like that's where they are in their awareness journey and they may need more time or a different medium than this board to get there. Doesn't mean they won't get there on their own timeline, but the same methods don't work for everyone. Well said, Alexandra!! Glad you joined for those last 10 yards! 👍 I agree that not only does participating on the boards promote our own healing and self-awareness but is also so valuable in learning conflict resolution and communication skills among the different styles. So incredibly insightful too not just hearing DA POV but reading some of the posts by AP can help me see how we can come across to our partners...love the 360 POV! 💫🙂
|
|
|
Post by ocarina on Nov 7, 2018 15:04:45 GMT
www.youtube.com/watch?v=Utsyj8bIbBkThese guys are my friends and I sing with them on and off - so the above is a plug, it's also relevant to this thread and finally it's imh epic!
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 9, 2018 16:16:02 GMT
This forum has been truly amazing for me. It has given me something therapy cannot and that's real people's thoughts and opinions. It is invaluable, in my opinion, so why would I want to censor that? That's what makes this board real. Even when feathers get ruffled, there is something to be learned in what is said and in the interaction. I can see people challenging old thoughts and opinions about themselves, their relationships and how they relate. Disagreements are healthy and a learning experience.
When I first came to this forum, I might have been seen as the "dreaded DA", I don't know. I keep coming here, because there is so much insight to be gained from others of all types. When I comment, it's not meant to ruffle feathers, and it might not even be aimed at the OP. If I can help give one person some insight they haven't thought about, it makes me happy. I want everyone to gain as much from this board that I have.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 9, 2018 16:28:52 GMT
This forum has been truly amazing for me. It has given me something therapy cannot and that's real people's thoughts and opinions. It is invaluable, in my opinion, so why would I want to censor that? That's what makes this board real. Even when feathers get ruffled, there is something to be learned in what is said and in the interaction. I can see people challenging old thoughts and opinions about themselves, their relationships and how they relate. Disagreements are healthy and a learning experience. When I first came to this forum, I might have been seen as the "dreaded DA", I don't know. I keep coming here, because there is so much insight to be gained from others of all types. When I comment, it's not meant to ruffle feathers, and it might not even be aimed at the OP. If I can help give one person some insight they haven't thought about, it makes me happy. I want everyone to gain as much from this board that I have. absolutely. and this board would be worthless to me without other DA sharing frankly and candidly, because that's my support right there. they are like me. they get me. when i hear the other DA express their perspective, it helps me. if they were not here i wouldn't be either.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Nov 10, 2018 11:35:34 GMT
Gosh...so much good stuff... juniper and goldilocks and @mary .....please keep showing up and keeping it real...those of us who are AP and are here for healing will eventually come around to understand the value you add. I came here wanting to understand B...I read every single post in the DA and FA sections trying to find a key that would unlock what I thought was lost...I was in such pain...but all I knew was to try to understand him so I could win him back. I credit this site with helping to push me beyond my limited personalized thinking.....to see that my view is not the only view and that my thoughts and behavior patterns were stuck and broken. That I had this incredibly unrealistic expectation on myself to be perfect and on B to save me from my past. It was incredibly dis functional. I also credit this site in helping me get the medical help I truly needed but had been so resistant towards for decades...it has changed my entire life in ways that are very hard to explain but are so very freeing. I feel authentic for the very first time in my life and that is so huge. I really do thank everyone who has stuck by me through the muck.....I know it must have felt so "icky" (yes..that is my technical term for it) to several posters to read my threads. Shirley Turkle has a TED talk that is really good about how technology is changing our interactions with each other.
|
|
andy
Full Member
Posts: 131
|
Post by andy on Dec 9, 2018 18:06:41 GMT
Thanks Andy for your kindness and honesty - one thing that commenting can lean me towards is somehow feeling more sorted than the people I am giving advice to - I think that most of us must be here - unless we are saints and truly altruistic (and that's possible of course) because something in the interaction makes us feel good. It's good and healthy to remember that we are all human and that our certainty about the right course of action is only a perception and the more we believe in it and cling to it - and try to push it onto others, the closer it becomes to some kind of extremism (not sure that's quite the right word). It certainly helps me to be humble and to own these things in myself - in real life I appear extremely calm and perhaps for this reason and because I am resilient and self contained, people often come to me for advice and support - I have had to notice that this can make me feel detached and superior (I don't really feel superior and try my hardest to live with humility but the feeling is there if I choose to notice it). Good practice to interact with others who are not in agreement with me and accept their way of being and my own can live in harmony without one being more right than the others. We humans like to cling to certainty in a world which is anything but. Thank you for your honest self-reflections, ocarina - it really opens up space for me to be honest about the way my mind works on here. For me the biggest negative aspect of the way I engage with this forum (or with social media, though I don't really post there anymore) is my focus on validation (likes, replies, etc.). So very AP - it's like I'm more AP here than in the rest of my life. Maybe there's a great opportunity to work at it here, or maybe the format of the online interaction gets in the way of my doing the work. I've been away over a month and almost forgot about the forum, and now that I'm back I have the urge to look at it a lot again, even when I'm out somewhere and would rather be feeling engaged in whatever I'm doing. My friend is staying with me from out of town this weekend, so maybe I crave the little introvert moments on my phone where I'm not engaging with him every minute? (He is sleeping now.) I do notice, though, that my attention span for attachment-related topics is a lot shorter than it once was, and I don't want to read every thread (or even close to that many threads). I think it's probably a sign that I've made a bit of progress - certainly the issues with my ex have settled down significantly, even if they aren't 100% resolved. Normally I am not strongly opinionated that people should do things a certain way or be a certain way. But I notice a judgmental side of myself coming out around topics that trigger me. One of these is the debate about whether our communications should be deliberately framed to convey care and minimize hurt to others, or whether we all should learn to be okay with all messages delivered with honesty and without ill will. And probably that is not really an either/or proposition, though it often ends up being a debate with two main sides. The word "should" is definitely a sign that it is a debate about values and there are some judgements involved. I do notice "should" statements coming up in myself around this question (even if I try to avoid using them in reference to others in my writing here), and with a lot of intensity that shows something is being triggered. Like you, I try to rein myself in if I observe that I'm getting judgemental and think I have THE answer for everyone and all situations. Maybe it is tricky for me as an AP because my tendency is often to doubt my own beliefs when someone disagrees with me and defer often to others and let others have the last word. So I get confused about whether my path for growth in any given moment is to speak out in support of my values, or to cultivate humility and acknowledge openly that my perspective is limited. And again, maybe not an either/or thing.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 15, 2019 23:42:22 GMT
I view this forum as an information sharing venue. I happen to think that the internet is very useful when used as a source of information and discussion for topics that one is seeking information about. As far as using it as a support network of an emotional nature, my opinion is that is misusing the medium. That's just my opinion. I'm sure people here will disagree. I believe in prioritizing real life aupport systems for sharing of an emotional nature that requires a lot of padding and "there, there" kind of interaction. Coming to the internet for answers, in a mature ways means realizing that not everyone shares your expectations for what you seek, and that it is a collection of strangers with unverified identities whom you do now know or can even verify the intent of.
Relationships are very different from cars. That said, if you turn to an internet forum for relationship advice, and opinions, recognize that you are not turning to your best friend, or therapist, or personal support group. You are asking a variety of individuals with very different perspectives and opinions for their input. Not everyone appreciates a lot of bubble wrap and emotional caretaking when seeking advice, or sharing their struggles that they are seeking answers for. Some of us appreciate information more than squishy soft conversations that make us feel good but don't give us anything new. If there is disagreement that doesn't have to be painful, does it? Maybe for some it is. It can be annoying but is that really horrible? I do see it like going on the internet to gain insight to find out why your car isn't running. Sure you might feel really emotional and stressed about that... How horrible is it to have your transportation down. Maybe you have no money and have spent your last dime and you're screwed. But if you go to the internet expect practical advice and support rather than a bunch of hand holding. If you are super upset and need hand holding go to someone in person who can and wants to do that for you.
Obviously we all feel very differently about this. But people ARE different and not everyone thinks getting super chummy and emotionally vulnerable on the net is healthy or desirable. Some of us think that belongs in real life and I am one. I'm sure it is a difference between styles, and I am also aware that some styles here are way more prevalent than others . Welcome to be internet. Bring your skin.
|
|