|
Post by mysteryuser on Apr 6, 2023 1:57:02 GMT
I (23F, AP leaning secure) have been working on my anxious side in therapy and recently got out of a relationship with someone (presumably FA) who I often found to be conflict avoidant. I knew this about him, but I didn't quite understand his attachment and its implications on the relationship - until it ended without him fully explaining why. This was my first serious relationship. And while my AP-ness brushed a few things under the rug while abandoning myself, some of it was simply me trying to understand how a relationship works for the first time. I have come a long way and am able to identify people who are consistently affectionate, reciprocal, and meet my needs in terms of connection, intimacy, and feeling loved. I had all of those in this past relationship. However, I didn't have someone who had the tools to work on themselves and consequently work on the relationship together to find effective solutions (we had a year long relationship where he broke up with me twice, both times seemed like I was blindsided).
I'm now trying to identify traits that reflect those qualities. Love is not enough, so what is? And how do I identify those traits?
A few things that I believe could reflect those are: resilience, a growth mindset, the acceptance of the inevitability of conflict (my vocabulary might be failing me here!), and of course, effective and non-violent communication.
But I'm confused as to how to identify these traits in people during the dating stages. How long do they take to reflect? What aspects of life reflect it? For example, my ex had a growth mindset in some aspects of life (work, fitness) and while he was willing to hear me out and read/watch videos I'd share regarding things like attachment styles or relationships, he didn't do that work on his own. I could have identified some of this early on, but some of it wasn't apparent to me until almost a year down the line.
What are the some other traits you have witnessed in people that are able to put in the work to make a relationship thrive? How do you identify those traits.
I completely understand some of these might as well be character traits and not necessarily attachment related, but sometimes my AP is unable to find the differences between the two and I'm trying to navigate that. I'm also trying to avoid identifying traits reflecting a certain attachment style because I don't want to get sucked into trying to diagnose other people, and I want to focus on the traits that soothe me as an AP instead.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Apr 6, 2023 3:54:47 GMT
I don’t look at it as traits but as someone who is able to think and act from 3 levels….me(meaning the person is able to communicate from an I perspective, is able to be personally responsible, has a good self esteem, has flexible boundaries), you ( meaning that person also considers the other person, not through an “I” lens..as in projecting or assuming, but really getting to know and understand the other person, consider’s the other person’s needs) and finally us (ie..the couple bubble….a person who makes decisions while considering both people, is committed to having healthy conversations and disagreements, is supportive of both people growing). I think the best way to find a healthy partner is to be a healthy partner (that means recognizing when someone is insecure and instead of hoping they will want to change, to let that person go). That can be tough when there are still aspects of insecurity that are driving behaviors…such as seeing the potential of a person versus seeing who that person really is or looking to another person to sooth anxiety or believing that if 1 person does most of the relationship work the other person will be inspired to do more also…There really isn’t a leaning secure…there are 3 insecure attachment styles and only 1 that is secure….people can earn secure….but it takes time.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Apr 6, 2023 4:11:20 GMT
Just to add…
But I'm confused as to how to identify these traits in people during the dating stages. How long do they take to reflect? What aspects of life reflect it? For example, my ex had a growth mindset in some aspects of life (work, fitness) and while he was willing to hear me out and read/watch videos I'd share regarding things like attachment styles or relationships, he didn't do that work on his own. I could have identified some of this early on, but some of it wasn't apparent to me until almost a year down the line.
Working through insecure attachment wounding is a very personal choice. I do not recommend showing a person videos on attachment theory. It is fine for you to share your own journey…but..if you cannot accept a person right where that person is at the moment, it is best to just walk away.
|
|
|
Post by mysteryuser on Apr 6, 2023 4:30:24 GMT
Working through insecure attachment wounding is a very personal choice. I do not recommend showing a person videos on attachment theory. It is fine for you to share your own journey…but..if you cannot accept a person right where that person is at the moment, it is best to just walk away. Oh I completely understand. This was 2 clips around the time we first broke up, and not from the lens of trying to diagnose or psychoanalyze but more so from the hope that he knows that something like attachment styles exist. I've mentioned it perhaps twice in the year long relationship, and only ever mentioned that *I* know what I am and am trying to work on myself. The focus has always been on trying to explain my perspective.
And thanks for the perspective. I think looking at it from the lens of the 3 levels makes sense. I'm definitely guilty of the insecure traits you listed and I'm trying to heal, but this idea of 3 levels is succinct yet comprehensive.
One thing that struck me was good self-esteem as a healthy trait. Of course there is no denying that. My ex did not have good self-esteem. While I know the problems that come with that, it is hard to separate feelings of compassion and care while trying to protect myself when navigating such relationships. It was really hard for me to not empathize and abandon myself whenever his low self-esteem manifested, because yes it was my AP wanting him to be okay because I wanted the relationship to be okay, but there was also a huge part of me just wanting him to be okay.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Apr 6, 2023 5:12:41 GMT
Working through insecure attachment wounding is a very personal choice. I do not recommend showing a person videos on attachment theory. It is fine for you to share your own journey…but..if you cannot accept a person right where that person is at the moment, it is best to just walk away. Oh I completely understand. This was 2 clips around the time we first broke up, and not from the lens of trying to diagnose or psychoanalyze but more so from the hope that he knows that something like attachment styles exist. I've mentioned it perhaps twice in the year long relationship, and only ever mentioned that *I* know what I am and am trying to work on myself. The focus has always been on trying to explain my perspective.
And thanks for the perspective. I think looking at it from the lens of the 3 levels makes sense. I'm definitely guilty of the insecure traits you listed and I'm trying to heal, but this idea of 3 levels is succinct yet comprehensive.
One thing that struck me was good self-esteem as a healthy trait. Of course there is no denying that. My ex did not have good self-esteem. While I know the problems that come with that, it is hard to separate feelings of compassion and care while trying to protect myself when navigating such relationships. It was really hard for me to not empathize and abandon myself whenever his low self-esteem manifested, because yes it was my AP wanting him to be okay because I wanted the relationship to be okay, but there was also a huge part of me just wanting him to be okay.
I recognize that trait because I have it also……I dated someone who had low self esteem and it endeared me to him…..but what I failed to appreciate is that I could still be there for him in a very different context (meaning I could wish him well but keep my healthy boundaries). That caring comes from a very sweet place and I would not want to give it up completely…but, when it starts to be about caring for someone else to the detriment of my own self care…that is a red flag. 🙂
|
|
|
Post by mrob on Apr 6, 2023 16:08:39 GMT
The irony is that “detachment with love” honours personal boundaries. It gives me the ability to be me. The lines aren’t blurred between you and me, which is refreshing.
|
|
|
Post by mysteryuser on Apr 6, 2023 18:59:56 GMT
The irony is that “detachment with love” honours personal boundaries. It gives me the ability to be me. The lines aren’t blurred between you and me, which is refreshing.
I can see this perspective. It also prevents the reinforcement of core wounds in some ways by discarding the notion that someone needs to be fixed/rescued (where the underlying reason is the person is damaged). In some ways it's easier for the AP in me to detach/let go because it's better for the other person and not because it's better for me. Despite being an AP trait, I wonder if that's enough because even if my feelings are anxious my actions are not.
|
|
|
Post by trippintre on Apr 6, 2023 19:42:27 GMT
I can relate to your situation and ex relationship a lot and went through something similar recently. I’ve been thinking about these same questions. I’ve been trying to approach it from a perspective of what are the flags that someone is not able to show up for someone fully rather than focusing on looking for traits that they are. In my last relationship, I was given plenty of warning signs that I ignored and shouldn’t have (low self esteem, workaholic, can’t ever just rest is always on the go/doing activities, self proclaimed people pleaser, rushes into relationships, etc) I am new to relationships as well so I was naive to a lot of this prior to my ex. Now that I have seen how it played out after ignoring them, I would wayyyyy more easily be able to identify these traits as red flags rather than an excuse to give someone the benefit of the doubt and hope things will be different with me if I can give them what they seemingly need. It may make relationships end quicker in the future but that’s a good thing as it would then spare me another heartbreaking blindside again.
|
|
|
Post by mysteryuser on Apr 6, 2023 23:14:25 GMT
trippintre thanks for sharing - I could have written that to a T As someone who was his sole source of emotional support, I think that is also a red flag because the second you drop the basket they've placed all their eggs in (be it due to a genuine mistake/ignorance or something in your life that distracted you), they lose their source of emotional support and can't cope. I think that and extreme conflict avoidance are major red flags that my inner AP ignored and I'm now left in a pickle!
|
|
|
Post by cherrycola on Apr 7, 2023 3:57:13 GMT
For me it's if I notice a person has black and white thinking/right vs wrong. As someone who used to only think in black and white, it blocked being able to understand someone else's perspective and a "we" approach. The right vs wrong was related to that black and white. It was if you are right then I am wrong and my ego can't handle that. Instead neither is wrong (in most cases) we each have our own perspective and it's powerful to communicate and understand each other to work through the conflict.
|
|
|
Post by alexandra on Apr 7, 2023 9:05:30 GMT
Someone who doesn't push for and enjoy conflict for its own sake, but also doesn't shy away from it as a bad, scary thing either is someone who can probably take a mature approach to communication and problem-solving. It's again, in my opinion, semantically not about finding people who "put in the work," it's about finding people with whom conflict-resolution isn't usually a draining chore. Trying to problem-solve together seems natural and organic because you're on the same team searching for a solution instead of being adversarial, and you've both earned that trust in each other over time observing that you both have good intentions and respect for each other. That heated discussion still comes from a good place with some consideration of "us" instead of frequent selfishness and needing to WIN, or taking an entirely fear-based approach to conflict and acting on that. You're trying to build a safe connection and strong foundation with another person over time, and in my opinion it's more important to focus on that and if they're in earnest doing the same than gauge it as "work." And it's important that the other person fights fair, instead of lashing out, intentionally saying hurtful things just for the sake of it, or projecting or making the conflict about a bunch of other unrelated things (especially drudging up old topics that have already been fully resolved, or being hypercritical and turning everything around on you with blame). Conflict doesn't have to mean things are on shakey ground, and it's important as an AP to always try to depersonalize and focus on the actual conflict to resolve instead of getting in your own head and insecurities about it. This is a pretty great thread about different ways things can get mixed up for insecures during stress and conflict, so there's layers piling up above and beyond the conflict at hand. jebkinnisonforum.com/thread/2372/overcoupling-stress-response It's also important things actually get resolved over time, and you don't just fight and repair with no actual resolution, only to keep repeating it over and over. This can all take some time, since you need to have a few conflicts first, or at least challenging / stressful external situations to get through together, to see how the other person meshes with you in this way. But it's incredibly important. It's also realistically not so easy to find someone who will have good approaches to relationships and conflict resolution in their early 20s, simply due to limited life experience so far. It's hard to know what styles of people you mesh best with and work through conflict with well when you've only, for example, dated one. So you having some patience and grace both for yourself and another person is also important, while not assuming the worst of them. Never abandon yourself and make excuses for why someone else should be allowed to make you feel small or disrespected, but everyone's also allowed to have bad days and bad moods sometimes and need some space to collect their thoughts (as long as they're not lashing out at you in the meantime). There's a naturally good balance for that which comes out of having a healthy sense of self-esteem and boundaries, trusting and accepting yourself while also trusting the other person (though not if they've given you solid reason to distrust them because they have shown themselves to be emotionally unsafe). On the AP side, those are areas to focus on about yourself. I think as far as dealing with security and insecurity goes, it's also good if someone doesn't leave you guessing. A person who will solidly show up for you will be direct with you about their feelings without games and confusion. Even if they are upset or overwhelmed, if they're emotionally mature enough they'll say, "I'm upset, but it's not you, I need to think about or deal with whatever it is and sort it out," and then they get back to you before too long has passed. Putting effort into things like the gym isn't the same as being open, vulnerable, resilient, and truly having a growth mindset. In my experience, especially with FAs, you will know if they're ready or not because if not you will at some point hit a wall on the relationship progression and momentum. Things will stop moving forward because the other person is comfortable exactly where they are with no further growth in the relationship. I've had that happen after 3 to 7 months, without fully comprehending it with those people for another couple months each and letting things last too long. But having breakups in the middle of the relationship is the biggest red flag, especially if there are multiple breakups and reconciliations. There shouldn't be any: breaking up is a last resort when communication and trust has completely failed, and it shouldn't be taken lightly.
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Apr 7, 2023 12:05:43 GMT
I saw this in an article and thought it was worth sharing…..
According to @therapyjeff, there are five relationship red flags every “honeymooner” should look out for: Overly controlling behavior, jealousy and possessiveness, lack of boundaries, conflict avoidance and over-dependency.
|
|
|
Post by mysteryuser on Apr 7, 2023 14:03:35 GMT
alexandra Thank you for sharing! Re: conflict, I agree wholeheartedly. One of my mistakes during conflict after the first break up was fawning, that I've now realized comes from my childhood where my parents walked out on each other multiple times, leaving me in the dark about whether they will be back and when, and I responded with doing literally whatever I could to put out the fire and keep peace. With him, it happened during a couple conflicts after the first break up if he would shut down/stonewall (which is now a total red flag for me). That said, he was extremely conflict avoidant - he wanted to minimize all miscommunication/misunderstanding/conflict. In fact he said he would prefer none but he knew that wasn't realistic (another flag I didn't see as red)! After conflict, it felt as if he didn't seem to trust that I still cared - which was one of his core wounds that I triggered towards the end. We lacked the "we" approach and we both had a part to play in that, but I did always bring up whatever I was bothered by (though I've realized more in hindsight) for the health of the relationship. But in terms of keeping me guessing, he did stonewall and that would make me fear abandonment and keep me guessing despite me requesting him multiple times after the first break up to try to say something along the lines of "we're going to be okay but X is bothering me", just to reassure me of his faith in us. Of course I still need to work through this fear and accept that me hearing those words or feeling terribly anxious is not going to change whether the person leaves or not. I also need to work on better non-violent communication. I definitely didn't do a good job establishing and enforcing boundaries in the name of intimacy, and I'm working on it. I realized much after a friend pointed it out that I was his sole source of emotional support, because he didn't talk to his friends or family about his pain. I knew it was unhealthy and I regularly suggested he talk to friends or a therapist in addition to me about a few external stressors, he didn't want to because he said he wanted my support instead, and I was ultimately okay with it (figuring out why as we speak). That was a huge responsibility because the second I made a mistake - be it due to ignorance or genuine distraction - he would lose his emotional support entirely. I realized this too late and ultimately this is what happened. He felt I didn't care about him, because I couldn't show up exactly how he wanted. I will admit I made mistakes and wasn't attentive "enough" (ie. didn't ask enough questions) about an external stressor in his life because I felt distracted by my own home (parents separated) and visa/legal stressors and assumed he would talk to me unprompted. Though I did ultimately start showing more attention - in ways that I didn't know he preferred until quite late - and he mentioned he appreciated that change, he ultimately didn't feel the same towards me anymore and wanted to leave. I wanted him to trust after a year that I care about him deeply and I show it in a lot of my words and actions despite failing to ask questions. But even if I had done everything right, a lot of his pain was linked to his core wound of people not caring and it would manifest one way or another (he would sometimes feel this about his evidently loving family - but I know he was in ways neglected in childhood due to family circumstances).
In my own naivety and lack of experience I did take him back the first time (after 3 days of being broken up) though I was slow to let him in after observing a few behavioral changes. But I know now that those changes were during good times and not stressful periods, because things went back to how they were once there was an external stressor. Change of this sort takes time especially if at their nervous core people have different fight/flight/fawn responses. I know now not to accept this behavior because not communicating issues and patiently trying to work through them before pulling the trigger is a major red flag to me now. We live and learn!
All of this said, I realize my APness has a lot to do with my childhood and fear of loneliness. I can eventually work through the childhood (I'm confident and have made tons of progress in other parts of my life with consistent therapy), but I don't know how to deal with the latter. I attribute a lot of pain with loneliness because of my childhood yes, but also simply because I want a family. It is something I absolutely want out of life, so I don't know if that fear can really be worked through or if it's something I need to live with. One approach could very well be better behaviors and stronger boundaries to find what I want despite that fear. I don't know if there are other approaches?
|
|
|
Post by tnr9 on Apr 7, 2023 14:55:29 GMT
alexandra Thank you for sharing! Re: conflict, I agree wholeheartedly. One of my mistakes during conflict after the first break up was fawning, that I've now realized comes from my childhood where my parents walked out on each other multiple times, leaving me in the dark about whether they will be back and when, and I responded with doing literally whatever I could to put out the fire and keep peace. With him, it happened during a couple conflicts after the first break up if he would shut down/stonewall (which is now a total red flag for me). That said, he was extremely conflict avoidant - he wanted to minimize all miscommunication/misunderstanding/conflict. In fact he said he would prefer none but he knew that wasn't realistic (another flag I didn't see as red)! After conflict, it felt as if he didn't seem to trust that I still cared - which was one of his core wounds that I triggered towards the end. We lacked the "we" approach and we both had a part to play in that, but I did always bring up whatever I was bothered by (though I've realized more in hindsight) for the health of the relationship. But in terms of keeping me guessing, he did stonewall and that would make me fear abandonment and keep me guessing despite me requesting him multiple times after the first break up to try to say something along the lines of "we're going to be okay but X is bothering me", just to reassure me of his faith in us. Of course I still need to work through this fear and accept that me hearing those words or feeling terribly anxious is not going to change whether the person leaves or not. I also need to work on better non-violent communication. I definitely didn't do a good job establishing and enforcing boundaries in the name of intimacy, and I'm working on it. I realized much after a friend pointed it out that I was his sole source of emotional support, because he didn't talk to his friends or family about his pain. I knew it was unhealthy and I regularly suggested he talk to friends or a therapist in addition to me about a few external stressors, he didn't want to because he said he wanted my support instead, and I was ultimately okay with it (figuring out why as we speak). That was a huge responsibility because the second I made a mistake - be it due to ignorance or genuine distraction - he would lose his emotional support entirely. I realized this too late and ultimately this is what happened. He felt I didn't care about him, because I couldn't show up exactly how he wanted. I will admit I made mistakes and wasn't attentive "enough" (ie. didn't ask enough questions) about an external stressor in his life because I felt distracted by my own home (parents separated) and visa/legal stressors and assumed he would talk to me unprompted. Though I did ultimately start showing more attention - in ways that I didn't know he preferred until quite late - and he mentioned he appreciated that change, he ultimately didn't feel the same towards me anymore and wanted to leave. I wanted him to trust after a year that I care about him deeply and I show it in a lot of my words and actions despite failing to ask questions. But even if I had done everything right, a lot of his pain was linked to his core wound of people not caring and it would manifest one way or another (he would sometimes feel this about his evidently loving family - but I know he was in ways neglected in childhood due to family circumstances).
In my own naivety and lack of experience I did take him back the first time (after 3 days of being broken up) though I was slow to let him in after observing a few behavioral changes. But I know now that those changes were during good times and not stressful periods, because things went back to how they were once there was an external stressor. Change of this sort takes time especially if at their nervous core people have different fight/flight/fawn responses. I know now not to accept this behavior because not communicating issues and patiently trying to work through them before pulling the trigger is a major red flag to me now. We live and learn!
All of this said, I realize my APness has a lot to do with my childhood and fear of loneliness. I can eventually work through the childhood (I'm confident and have made tons of progress in other parts of my life with consistent therapy), but I don't know how to deal with the latter. I attribute a lot of pain with loneliness because of my childhood yes, but also simply because I want a family. It is something I absolutely want out of life, so I don't know if that fear can really be worked through or if it's something I need to live with. One approach could very well be better behaviors and stronger boundaries to find what I want despite that fear. I don't know if there are other approaches?
The good new is you have time to find the right partner to create a family with. One way to address loneliness is to have hobbies that connect you to others. There are dating groups that I have seen that are activity based…like cooking, sports etc. That might be something to explore because there is a bit less pressure to find “the one” and really just enjoy the activity with others. Another thing you can do is find a sport or activity you enjoy and find groups that are centered around that activity. I have a friend who loves to run and she is part of several groups of runners who get together and practice before races…but there are a lot of other options. I had to address my fear of loneliness by taking myself out on dates….I know that may sound a bit silly, but becoming ok with being “single” is a actually a good thing.Go to a play, a park, a museum, a restaurant by yourself….treat yourself the way you would want a date to treat you. It has such a positive impact on your self esteem.
|
|
|
Post by trippintre on Apr 7, 2023 15:14:41 GMT
I will admit I made mistakes and wasn't attentive "enough" (ie. didn't ask enough questions) about an external stressor in his life because I felt distracted by my own home (parents separated) and visa/legal stressors and assumed he would talk to me unprompted. Though I did ultimately start showing more attention - in ways that I didn't know he preferred until quite late - and he mentioned he appreciated that change, he ultimately didn't feel the same towards me anymore and wanted to leave. I wanted him to trust after a year that I care about him deeply and I show it in a lot of my words and actions despite failing to ask questions. But even if I had done everything right, a lot of his pain was linked to his core wound of people not caring and it would manifest one way or another
[/div] [/quote] I noticed a lot of the same in my situation. My ex brought up randomly toward the end of our relationship during a serious discussion an example of a situation which made him second guess how close we were. To me, it seemed totally out of left field and nit-picky and especially odd that he wouldn’t say anything shortly after but instead wait till a month later to use it as this example of our closeness level. I have ruminated about this quite a bit because it really was confusing to me and made me wonder if I did something wrong or if he was right about us not being close. Ultimately, I feel like it doesn’t have anything to do with my behavior or how close we were. Same with your situation - it wasn’t that you didn’t ask “enough” questions or do anything wrong, it’s that if something bothered him about your behavior or if he needed something from you, it is his responsibility to communicate that instead of let it fester and use it as an example of incompatibility down the line. Same as what happened in my situation. If my ex needed something, he should have let me know. And when I asked him explicitly what he needs from me he said “I don’t know.” You can’t do much with that. The core wound is there no matter what - my ex even said he feels a lack of closeness with other people in his life sometimes, not just me. So there was an element of recognizing it’s a pattern but if someone hasn’t reached a certain level of awareness about the root of the issue, nothings gonna change.
|
|